Guest Stars Tim Bagley as Toby Pearson Ryan Caltagirone as Hot Dad Trevor Larcom as Blake Adam Korson as Kyle David Wain as Pastor Ted Ed Begley Jr. as John-Paul Bennigan Alley Mills as Joanna Bennigan Cloris Leachman as Memaw Co Starring Lisa Linke as Terry Brittini London as Brenda Renes Antonio Rivera as Paul-Luke Bex Marsh as Jacinda Symphony Grace as Flower Girl