Guest Stars Clark Middleton as Glen Carter Ken Leung as Assistant U.S. Attorney Michael Sima Becky Ann Baker as Judge Roberta Wilkins David Berman as Dr. Ogden Maguire Mark Linn-Baker as Dr. Jonathan Nikkila Richard Toth as Bob Lockemy Matthew Porretta as Schmock Co Starring Desi Waters as Court Clerk Kelley Curran as Co-Counsel Christianne Tisdale as Potential Juror #5 / Family of Crime Victim Liz McCartney as Potential Juror #4 / Pug Lady Lawrence Winslow as Potential Juror #6 / Veteran Guy Margo as Potential Juror #3 / Factory Worker Erika Woods as Officer Talbert Susan Oliveras as ER Nurse #2 Gerson Gomez as Tony Montez Tessa Frascogna as Girl Margaret Ivey as Staffer Cathy Salvodon as Potential Juror #2 / School Teacher Elizabeth Inghram as Surgeon Ralph Adriel Johnson as ER Nurse #1 Denia Brache as Rosa Nimo Gandhi as Abdul Kedir Randy Kovitz as Committee Chairman Jon Conver as Potential Juror #7 / Anarchist Nancy Meyer as Merriam Lockemy Lou Martini, Jr. as Potential Juror #1 / Cab Driver Clark Carmichael as Congressman #2