Guest Stars Caitlin Mehner as Heather Husband Catherine Lidstone as Isabel Sanchez Laurie Holden as Greta Bellows David Alpay as Dylan Elaine Hendrix as Susan Alders Shanesia Davis as Irene Boudreau Bryce Pinkham as Connor Mayfeld Jennifer Parsons as Helen Scott Josh Clark as Jack Scott Harry Jarvis as Young Levi Michael Graziadei as Jeff Skadden Tyla Abercrumbie as Tamara Folsom Therese Plaehn as Celeste Co Starring Casey Tutton as Rosemary Lynch James Farruggio as ASA Duncan Ben Marten as Brian Husband Patrick Clear as Clarence Meyers Nadia Simms as Audra Boudreau Phillip Cusic as Michael Boudreau Karen Woditsch as Municipal Judge Jennifer Latimore as ASA Green Mark Vallarta as David Kris Wolff as Detective Juliet Hart as Local Reporter Law Tarello as Chad Andy-John G. Kalkounos as Detective Waterman David Lively as Judge McGrath Mark Rademacher as Murray Bryce P.D. David Goodloe as Police Officer Harry Belden as Waiter Marco Elena Muntean as Bartender