Guest Stars Doug Jones as Baron Afanas Jake McDorman as Jeff Suckler Beanie Feldstein as Jenna Co Starring Gloria Laino as Baron's Familiar Mary Gillis as June Jon Gabrus as Wharfinger Hayden Szeto as Jonathan Kate Comer as Park Woman Jamison Webb as Park Man Casey Feigh as Game Master Warren Barrow as Cashier Uncredited Chris Perfetti as Kyle