Guest Stars Adam Goldberg as Simon Hayes Gaius Charles as Rev. Andrew Carver Stella Maeve as Sophia Zolfo Al Sapienza as Sonny Zolfo René Ifrah as Tony Co Starring Francesca Ling as Parker Robert McKay as Lester Lawrence Ballard as Will Cate Bottiglione as Hostess Scott Aiello as Gas Worker Zoey Martinson as Caroline Jackson Aiden Flowers as Marcus