Guest Stars Caitlin Mehner as Heather Husband Laurie Holden as Greta Bellows Tiffany Dupont as Nikki Castro David Alpay as Dylan Elaine Hendrix as Susan Alders Shanesia Davis as Irene Boudreau Brett Rice as Charles Lynch Harry Jarvis as Young Levi John Cothran, Jr. as Pastor White Tembi Locke as Vanessa Dale Natalija Nogulich as Barbara Lynch Jason Woods as William Hurston Co Starring Casey Tutton as Rosemary Lynch James Farruggio as ASA Duncan Ben Marten as Brian Husband Patrick Clear as Clarence Meyers James Krag as Joe Welch Nadia Simms as Audra Boudreau Eddie Diaz as Evan Esteban-Miller Phillip Cusic as Michael Boudreau Wendye Clarendon as Jennifer Briggs Diana Boos as Foreperson Bill Busse as Prison Guard #1 Gabrielle Lott-Rogers as Patricia Mitchell Joe Foust as Leo Toth Randall McDonald as Man John Lu as Odd Comic Book Nerd Keith Kupferer as Detective Folino Max Ganet as Thomas Radcliff Carmen Roman as Judge Licata Ira Amyx as Dr. Gregson Karen Woditsch as Judge Boxer