Guest Stars James Lesure as FBI Agent Jim Turner Zach Gilford as Greg David Hornsby as Leslie "Boomer" Peterson Caleb Emery as Baby Tyler Allison Tolman as Mary Pat Sally Pressman as Nancy June Squibb as Marion Peterson Damien Leake as Pastor Collins Co Starring Everleigh McDonell as Jane Boland Scarlett Abinante as Emma Boland Mason Shea Joyce as Danny Boland Braxton Bjerken as Kenny Boland Kue Lawrence as Benji Jay Jackson as Nate Noah Salsbury Lipson as Andy Ian Sharkey as Billy Amanda Reed as Linda Ivan Leung as Customer Matt Price as Car Customer Joanna Leeds as Shelby Shaun Clay as Valet Shea Scullin as Karl