Guest Stars Autumn Reeser as Angela Ben Donovan as Kenny Kristin Dattilo as Mrs. Milfner Amber Stevens West as Girl no. 2 Adam Cagley as Boy no. 1 Steven Gilborn as Town Councilman Christopher Darga as Mr. Milfner Alejandro Rose-Garcia as Boy no. 2 Erin Wideman as Girl no. 1 Vinnie Pergola as Mikey