Guest Stars Olivia Sandoval as Celia Chavez Michael Beach as Douglas Delap Obba Babatundé as Phillip Kaws José Zúñiga as Randy Stanton Marshall Allman as Herbert Brooks Elizabeth Schmidt as Debra O'Donnell Mark Jude Sullivan as Mr. Ogoff Noah Khyle as Rory Blinken Co Starring Rahvaunia L. Johnson as Theresa Wood Brandon Win as Paralegal Shea Buckner as Rob Humphreville Alison Robertson as Jury Foreperson Walter Fauntleroy as Isaiah West Lizzie Zerebko as Allyson Smith