Guest Stars D'Arcy Carden as Natalie Greer Michael Irby as Cristobal Sifuentes Rightor Doyle as Nick Nicholby Darrell Britt-Gibson as Jermaine Jefrint Kirby Howell-Baptiste as Sasha Baxter Alejandro Furth as Antonio Manuel Andy Carey as Eric John Pirruccello as Detective Loach Jessy Hodges as Lindsay Mandel Andrew Leeds as Leo Cousineau Sarah Burns as Detective Mae Dunn Patricia Fa'Asua as Esther Chris McGarry as Michael Rodney To as Mike Michael Beach as Police Detective Co Starring Patrick Fabian as Space Dad Elle Evans as Prosecutor Ethan Jones as Space Kid Ludwig Manukian as District Attorney McGarrity