Guest Stars Pat Finn as Phil Valerie Azlynn as Sula Becky O'Donohue as Julia David Starzyk as Evan Brady Smith as Chad Gattlin Griffith as Helmet Boy Rebecca Metz as Mother Mark Brandon as Cute Guy Julian Berlin as Lena Julie Wittner as Wendy Michael Yurchak as Prince Charming Ahna O'Reilly as Blind Hostess Marc Goldsmith as Dad Skye Depasquale as Blind Waitress