Guest Stars Brett Tucker as Lucas Ripley Lisseth Chavez as Kathleen Jasika Nicole as Mila Sam Anderson as Elliot Co Starring BJ Tanner as Tuck Sarah Oh as Jenna Matson Matthew Wimbush as Officer Gates Vivien Lyra Blair as Penny Brian Tichnell as Trevor Tia Valentine as Slumber Partier Alek Cole as Xander Hermie Castillo as Graham