Guest Stars Andrew Terraciano as Sean Reagan Abigail Hawk as Det. Abigail Baker Gregory Jbara as DCPI Garrett Moore Robert Clohessy as Sid Gormley Tony Terraciano as Jack Reagan Steven R. Schirripa as Anthony Abetemarco Lauren Patten as Rachel Witten Stacy Keach as Archbishop Kevin Kearns Christine Ebersole as Lena Janko Sydney Farley as Rachel Wilson Laura Poe as Valerie Harris Erin Gann as Leo Morris Co Starring Darik Bernard as Officer Irving Matthew Hardy as Brent Alston (Reporter) Julia Blanchard as Sarah Fisher Connor McGee as Patrick Harris Damian Muziani as Super Amber Owens as Female Prosecutor Jamil A.C. Mangan as Lawyer Uncredited James Nuciforo as Jim Nuciforo