Guest Stars Wallace Shawn as Dr. John Sturgis Matt Hobby as Pastor Jeff Hodgkins Ryan Phuong as Tam Nguyen Rex Linn as Principal Tom Peterson Brian Stepanek as Mr. Hubert Givens Nancy Linehan Charles voices Peg Valerie Mahaffey as Ms. Victoria MacElroy Isabel May as Veronica Duncan Isabella Coben as Nell Cavanaugh Robert Clotworthy as Mayor Harrison Co Starring Annelise Grace as Abby Daniele Lawson as Shelby