Guest Stars Lachlan Watson as Susie Putnam / Theo Gavin Leatherwood as Nicholas Scratch Abigail F. Cowen as Dorcas Alessandro Juliani as Dr. Cerberus Jedidiah Goodacre as Dorian Gray Darren Mann as Luke Chalfant Alexis Denisof as Adam Marsters Graeme McComb as Gideon Liam Hughes as Quentin Corwin Spencer Treat Clark as Jerathmiel Bayley Corman as Mehitabel Co Starring Tyler Cotton as Melvin Emily Haine as Elspeth Christiaan Westerveld as Infernal Bailiff Gary Jones as Trivium #2 (Jury) Richard Ian Cox as Trivium #1 (Judge) Ryan Egan as Trivium #3 (Executioner)