Guest Stars Emily Swallow as AUSA Audrey Valdez Laila Robins as Colleen McCandless Mandy June Turpin as Judge Hamilton Myles Clohessy as Brendan McCandless Thomas Francis Murphy as Donovan McCandless James Lurie as Keith O'Leary Joseph Ragno as Judge Weston Stanley Garrett Forster as Connor McCandless Co Starring Bill Kux as Juror #9 Johnny Rivera as Counterman Kim Brockington as Sheila Hartley Matt W. Cody as Juror #2 Boris Khaykin as Yuri Pasternak