Guest Stars Chance Kelly as Ed Cutler Ambyr Childers as Susan Atkins David Meunier as Roy Kovic Milauna Jackson as Kristin Shafe Tara Lynne Barr as Katie Jodi Harris as Opal Abby Miller as Mary Brunner Graham Beckel as Lieutenant Alex Quijano as Joe Moran Eddie Jones as Father Mack Brian Poth as Chris Doug Tompos as Lee Alexandra Krosney as Ms. Jens J.R. Mangels as Bert