Guest Stars David Cubitt as Ted Pownall Chad Rook as Chris Mueller Caroline Cave as Beth Marzdan Michael Rogers as Commander David Kyle Ary Katz as Mate Co Starring Georgia Waters as Eliza Katie Keough as Hunter (Mermaid) Broadus Mattison as Fisherman Stew McLean as Night Clerk Felix Adam Pateman as Some Drunk Hunter Golden as Drummer Steve Richmond as Lead Singer