Guest Stars Mo Collins as Sarah Rabinowitz Colby Hollman as Wes Daryl Mitchell as Wendell Colby Minifie as Virginia Peter Jacobson as Rabbi Jacob Kessner Ethan Suess as Max Bailey Gavulic as Annie Cooper Dodson as Dylan Matt Frewer as Logan Holly Curran as Janis Co Starring Cory Hart as Rollie Peggy Schott as Tess Mikala Gibson as Doris Beau Smith as Dom