Guest Stars Josh Hamilton as Matt Jensen Benito Martinez as Sheriff Diaz Nana Mensah as Amara Josephine Achola Brandon Scott as Coach Kerba Matthew Alan as Seth Maria Dizzia as Mrs. Down Tom Everett Scott as Mr. Down Bex Taylor-Klaus as Casey Ford Parminder Nagra as Priya Singh Co Starring Tyler Barnhardt as Charlie St. George Austin Aaron as Luke Holliday Robert Walker-Branchaud as Deputy Collins Ron Roggé as Coach Morris Ren Hanami as Social Worker