Guest Stars Laura Benanti as Quinn Tyler Michael Urie as Redmond Chris Tardio as Enzo De Luca Annaleigh Ashford as Shelly Rozansky Co Starring Camille Saviola as Filomena De Luca Stephanie DiMaggio as Valentina Nicholas Richardson as Nate Condon Teddy Coluca as Uncle Joe Christopher Harrod as Priest Christina Acosta Robinson as Band Singer