Guest Stars Melanie Field as Sunrise Darshan Cummings Marielle Scott as Lucy Sprecher Adwin Brown as Calvin Robin Lord Taylor as Will Chris D'Elia as Henderson Kether Donohue as Tina Co Starring Chelsea Sanders as Female Improviser Adam Chambers as Jonah Geoff Ross as Geoff Beth Appel as Beth Mark David Christenson as Mark Joel Wiersema as Improv Nerd Nina Concepción as Nina Sarah Claspell as Sarah Eliot Schwartz as Freddy Jake Regal as Jake Andy Cameron as Improv Dude #1