Guest Stars Josh Kelly as Robbie Ellis Fredric Lehne as Tommy Danny Johnson as Father Charles Jason Dohring as Blake Fullum Ethan McDowell as Richard Starks Ana Lucasey as Ava Fullum Davont'e Franklin as Maceo Co Starring Susan Williams as Deborah Androde Enya Flack as Rachel Lambert Zach Hanner as Mayor Ed Wagenseller as Board Member John Sneed as Dr. Miles Jones Bart Mallard as Coach Clark Joseph Hammer as John Marissa Cherry as Beth Courtney Lenz Moody as Christina Tracy L. Moore as Jury Foreman Josh Bond as Referee Patricia Smith as Judge Dunbar