Guest Stars Sherri Saum as Ellie Whedon Coby Bird as Rufus Whedon Genevieve Kang as Jackie Veda Eric Graise as Logan Calloway Martin Roach as Detective Daniel Matuko Felix Mallard as Lucas Caravaggio Steven Williams as Joe Ridgeway Co Starring Hallea Jones as Eden Hawkins Nicole James as Young Erin Voss Nick Dolan as Young Rendell Locke Sabrina Saudin as Young Ellie Whedon Owen Ois as Young Duncan Locke André Dae Kim as Young Mark Cho Ellen Giddings as Young Kim Topher Aidan Shaw as Young Jeff Ellis Ken Pak as Mark Cho Leslie Adlam as Infirmary Nurse Erika Nonato as Dorm Girl Erica Pickering as Kinsey's Fear Monster