Guest Stars Abigail F. Cowen as Dorcas Sam Corlett as Caliban Peter Bundic as Carl Tapper Alessandro Juliani as Dr. Cerberus Jonathan Whitesell as Robin Goodfellow Christopher Rosamond as Mr. Kinkle Luke Cook as Lucifer Morningstar / Dark Lord Jedidiah Goodacre as Dorian Gray Lucie Guest as CIrce Vanessa Rubio as Nagaina Will Swenson as Carcosa Co Starring Tyler Cotton as Melvin Ty Wood as Billy Marlin Emily Haine as Elspeth Nelson Leis as Beelzebub John Murphy as Asmodeus MJ Kokolis as Demonic Minion Xantha Radley as Mrs. Meeks Donald Sales as Purson Jasmine Vega as Lizzie Ian Rozylo as King Herod Fiona MacKellar Matthews as Salo Marcello Ranieri as De Sade Zavien Garrett as Teenage Boy
