Guest Stars Sam Corlett as Caliban Alessandro Juliani as Dr. Cerberus Jonathan Whitesell as Robin Goodfellow Skye P. Marshall as Mambo Michele Marie Le Fleur Lucie Guest as CIrce Glynis Davies as Dezmelda Vanessa Rubio as Nagaina Heather Doerksen as Gryla Kaylah Zander as Sycorax Will Swenson as Carcosa Leanne Khol Young as Pesta Maria Marlow as Mother Hubbard Oliver Rice as Barabbas Daniel Nemes as Pontius Pilate Co Starring Tyler Cotton as Melvin Ty Wood as Billy Marlin Peter Bundic as Carl Tapper Emily Haine as Elspeth Nelson Leis as Beelzebub John Murphy as Asmodeus Uncredited Sean Kuling as Centurion