Guest Stars Abigail F. Cowen as Dorcas Sam Corlett as Caliban Jonathan Whitesell as Robin Goodfellow Skye P. Marshall as Mambo Michele Marie Le Fleur Luke Cook as Lucifer Morningstar / Dark Lord Lucie Guest as CIrce Vanessa Rubio as Nagaina Will Swenson as Carcosa Mark Hildreth as Judas Iscariot Michael Antonakos as Vlad the Impaler Co Starring Tyler Cotton as Melvin Nelson Leis as Beelzebub John Murphy as Asmodeus MJ Kokolis as Demonic Minion Xantha Radley as Mrs. Meeks Georgie Daburas as Edward Spellman Donald Sales as Purson B.J. Harrison as Mrs. Curtis Jasmine Vega as Lizzie Brad Kelly as Strong Man #1 Spencer Lang as Strong Man #2 Cameron Andres as Young Blackwood Hayley Wilson as Young Zelda