Guest Stars Katherine LaNasa as Noa Havilland Tami Roman as Lillian Scoville Annabella Sciorra as Erin Buhrman Brett Cullen as Owen Cave Laura Allen as Alana Cave Indira G. Wilson as Shirley Maxwell Ray Stoney as C.O. Tuttle Al Rodrigo as TBD Co Starring Rico E. Anderson as Herbie Hunter Doohan as Teenage Warren Stella Weinstein as Young Lanie Caroline Huey as Teenage Lanie Rebecca Huey as Teenage Josie Mayson Weinstein as Young Josie Brooklynn MacKinzie as Young Poppy Michael Franklin as Young Shreve Makenzie Lee-Foster as Young Donnie Makeba Pace as Mayor Gloria Lemmons Robert Arce as Chris Harkin Tatum Shank as Curtis Mayes Kristen Marie Kelly as Receptionist / Stephanie Karl Risinger as Visitation Room C.O. Tony Raymond Wilde as Dave Lisa Linke as Rebecca Vonner Kate Enggren as Nurse Marybeth Keith Barber as Prison Chaplain E.J. Callahan as Nurse Tony Ciera Hart as Trini