Guest Stars Tony Nappo as Hank Neston Hannan Younis as Raz Ronnie Rowe as Wyatt Hudley Caitlin Howden as Sharon Beckbaum Atticus Mitchell as Travis Meeks Nikki Duval as Camilla Argento Rielle Braid as Amy Neston Leah Doz as Max Solomin Jody Threat as Donna Henderson Kristin Shepard as Tabitha McNurtt Tara Nicodemo as Zilla Miranda Millar as Noemie Hannah Spear as Hannah Alden Adair as Sam Aarons Melody Johnson as Elizabeth Mill Kelly Boegel as Esme Sabbins Yvonne Elizabeth Davidson as Agnes Christy Bruce as Vicki Zabrowski Ted Atherton as Josiah Noseworthy Emily Piggford as Lacey Kwan Kyle Dooley as Odin Telysa Chandler as Lisa Grover Lisa Merchant as Lead Juror Stewart Arnott voices Narrator John Corbett as Garth Bundles Patrick Kerton as Re-enactment William Oscar Hsu as Gary Wong Isaac Winters as Re-enactment Micky Bree Ali as Re-enactment Dana Stephanie Kast as Re-enactment Lisa Janice Gencher as Re-enactment Mary-Lynn Jaclyn Phillips as Re-enactment Hannah Kendall Wright as Re-enactment Katherine Limor Marks as Mary-Lynn Lafayette David Dino White as Micky Robin Frigeri as Jonny Kozinsky Rosemary Radcliffe as Greta Bundles Steven John Dixon as Re-enactment Sam Christine Cleary as Re-enactment Helen Nelu Handa as Dana Bashuk Megan Dawson as Middle Aged Woman