Guest Stars Brianna Baker as Nancy Gillian Mark Elias as Timothy "Tim" Rosewater Evan Arnold as Elliot Pasquale McKaley Miller as Brianna Mary Kay Place as Theresa Blake Brett Rice as Wayne Gettinger Margarita Franco as Nancy Juan Javier Cárdenas as Ray Madelyn Miranda as Ada Roman Coto as Nico Co Starring Nina Concepción as Bree Albert Kong as Zach Sean H. Scully as Caleb Danny Max as Reporter Rhett Wellington as Garrett Skylar Roberge as Jenny Danielle Hoetmer as Female Dispatcher #2