Guest Stars Allegra Edwards as Cindy McCabe Susan Park as Daphne Owens Timm Sharp as Harold Snow John Aylward as Freddie Laffter Rigo Sanchez as Eliseo David Zaldivar as Lalo Mel Rodriguez as Mayor Tony Salazar Edward Asner as James Staghorne Sr. David Paymer as Jimmy Jr. Melissa Tang as Grace Chow Peter Stormare as Gunther Co Starring Sarah Minnich as Ginger Galanti Michael Sare as Puppeteer #1 Trey Stokes as Puppeteer #2 Matthew Van Wettering as Rick Hardy Natalie Jaramillo as Amity Annacheska Brown as Mohawk Teen Ben Sanders as Rory Efrain Villa as Smuggler Maeve Garay as Mariposa Alex Hetlinger as Plinko