Guest Stars Joanna Going as Mary Fisher Frank Whaley as Detective James Connor Ebon Moss-Bachrach as Trey Carano Autry Haydon-Wilson as Young Amy Harlow Ray Santiago as Paul Manning Pat Healy as Robert Sullivan Roberta Colindrez as Detective Boyd Co Starring Jersey Johnston as Debbie Russell Ellen Humphreys as Sharon Russell Preston James Hillier as Gary Davis Lateef Crowder as Drunk Man Travis Hammer as Ed Kenneth McGlothin as Bob Taylor Robyn Reede as Desk Clerk Ben Nolte as Police Surveyor Bingham Sean Boyd as Mark Keller Jack O'Donnell as Ben Wilson Jacob Browne as Levon Genia Michaela as Lois Wilson Jean Effron as Katrina Johnson Esodie Geiger as Tina Morse Bicknell as Sheriff Red Rogers