Special Guest Stars Jeannie Berlin as Ruth Heidelbaum Guest Stars Jonno Davies as Tobias Henry Hunter Hall as Cheeks Johnson Julissa Bermudez as Maria De La Ruiz Megan Channell as Katarina Löw James Le Gros as Chief Harry Grimsby Miles G. Jackson as Danny Rohr Ronald Guttman as Moritz Ehrlich Becky Ann Baker as Juanita Kreps Josh Mostel as Rabbi Steckler Ben Livingston as President Jimmy Carter Anastasia Barzee as Annika Bauman Garth Kravits as Tommy Damato Co Starring Phoenix Noelle Reece as Malika Mary Jo McConnell as Una Joshua Satine as Aaron Markowitz Adam Gagan as Kosher Nostra #1 Judy Rosenblatt as Mrs. Schlosstein Steven Kaplan as Ben Rosenfeld Hannah Reid Rubinek as Amy Markowitz Hans Peterson as SS Nazi Guard #1 Anna Kathryn Holbrook as Sister Colin Iringó Réti as Stern Woman Balázs Csémy as Young Murray Gábor Jászberényi as Young Moritz Daniel Hackbarth as SS Nazi Guard #2 Bianka Tatar as Young Mindy Margot Weintraub as Convent Girl #2 Keeley Karsten as Convent Girl #1 Raphael Frieder as Cantor Anouk Xuereb as Rebekah Kreutzer Kristian Espiritu as Nurse Balázs Czukor as Avram Kreutzer Jon Bander as Emcee Barthelemy Atsin as Eric Greene