Guest Stars Cory Lee as Paige Andrew Dunbar as Officer Smith Dan Payne as Ethan Plume Lara Gilchrist as Margaret Vincent Ben Wilkinson as Ted Penn Stephen Lobo as Neil Garfunkle Anne Marie DeLuise as Beatrice Rebecca Davis as Rebecca Garfunkle Brenna O'Brien as Caroline Higgins Garrett Black as Peter Iris Quinn as Beth Parveen Dosanjh as Nancy Upton Jase Anthony Griffith as Carl Heather-Claire Nortey as Helen Travers Anthony Ingram as Hotel Desk Clerk Kelly McCabe as Ben Dave Santana as Neighbor Drew Weston as Thomas