Guest Stars Rory O'Malley voices Elwood Eugene Cordero voices Brendan Janelle James voices Fran Tony Shalhoub voices Marvin H. Jon Benjamin voices Mayor Whitney Whitebottom Jessica St. Clair voices Deb Dalyrumple David Herman voices Male Jogger David Herman voices Reporter Audra McDonald voices Ashley Danny Burstein voices Dick Flake Natalie Palamides voices Female Jogger