Guest Stars Daniel Henshall as Leonard Patz J.K. Simmons as Billy Barber Megan Byrne as Joan Rifkin Patrick Fischler as Dan Rifkin Tamara Hickey as Toby Daryl Edwards as Judge French Co Starring William Xifaras as Father O'Leary Marilyn Busch as Court Clerk Berlis Cuevas as Bailiff Jessi Case as Hope Connors Stephanie Bisono as Nurse Chelsea Hueter as Reporter