Guest Stars Michael Cotter as Lewis Slocombe Jordan Belfi as Neal Donovan Shashawnee Hall as Judge Thomas Watkins Ray Wise as Lloyd Holcomb Hayley Marie Norman as Charlotte Prosser Jennifer Aspen as April George Tom Virtue as Larry Reiner Eric Ladin as Ronald Harper Joy Lauren as Krystie Mays Jonno Roberts as Jano Sharon Tay as Herself Mo Gallini as Theo Samaha Kelli Kirkland Powers as Andrea Greer Geoffrey Rivas as Detective Roja Eli Goodman as Michael Green Mark Sivertsen as Marty Babish Co Starring Stefanie Butler as Taylor Mays Jason Graham as Party Guy Karen Elmore as Reporter