Special Guest Stars Jamie Lynn Spears as Noreen Fitzgibbons Guest Stars Dion Johnstone as Erik Whitley Chris Medlin as Isaac Downey Bianca Tarantino as Katie Townsend Tracey Bonner as Pastor June Wilkes Brittany L. Smith as Peggy Martin Caroline Lagerfelt as Paula Vreeland Frank Oakley III as Harlan Bixby Allison Gabriel as Mary Vaughn Lewis Shawn Passwaters as Dr. Howie Young Vickie Eng as Grace Wharton Charles Lawlor as Collins Littlefield Alpha Trivette as Neville Wharton Adam Fristoe as Brad Wellington Jason MacDonald as Tom Patterson