Guest Stars Paula Newsome as Pastor Nichelle del Rio Natalie Martinez as Ana Damon Wayans Jr. as Jason Grant Keegan Connor Tracy as Gloria Conley David Krumholtz as Mayor John Conley Andrew Alvarez as Emilio Co Starring Tim Zhang as Visitor #1 Peter New as Beau Marc Gaudet as Gas Station Owner Michael P. Northey as Cooper Christina Jastrzembska as Mrs. Turner Patrick Keating as Mr. Turner Linda Darlow as Esther Michael Tiernan as Farmer Krish Lohtia as Visitor #2 Jason Asuncion as Francisco Jeremy Arnold as Congregant Steel Bey as Ben Conley Kristine Wilson as News Reporter