Guest Stars Eric Lange as Detective Gene Holcomb Gayle Rankin as Emily Dodson Molly Ephraim as Hazel Prystock Andrew Howard as Detective Joe Ennis Robert Patrick as Herman Baggerly Lili Taylor as Birdy McKeegan Stephen Root as Maynard Barnes David Wilson Barnes as Elder Brown Veronica Falcón as Lupe Gibbs Taylor Nichols as Elder Eric Q. Seidel Matt Frewer as Judge Frederick Wright Gretchen Mol voices Linda Mason Jefferson Mays as Virgil Sheets Jenny O'Hara as June Pitlick Matt Malloy as Frank C. Dillon Michael McMillian as Oliver Fogg Hemky Madera as Rigoberto Adam O'Byrne as Tod Robbins Ely Henry as Frank Lott Co Starring David St. James as Dr. Bundy Bobby Gutierrez as Chubby Carmichael Carly Nykanen as Mom Brian T. Finney as Emcee Joshua Dov as Danny Rahway Jim Hanna as Jon Daily Karen Brundage as Partial Crowd Person John Grady as Luke Metuchen Thomas Crawford as Golfer Connor Barrett as Brian Strand Doug Hurley as Assistant Attorney Kendra Chell as Crowd Well Wisher Damone Paul Jackson as Stanley Dan Leahy as Caddie Troy Vincent as Lucas Rhodes Liliana Clingingsmith as Little Girl James Larson as Choir Kid