Guest Stars Amy Ryan voices Michelle McNamara Patton Oswalt as Himself Paul Haynes as Himself Lauren Orlando as Michelle McNamara Melanie Barbeau as Herself Kris Pedretti as Herself Larry Crompton as Himself Paul Holes as Himself Karen Kilgariff as Herself Billy Jensen as Himself Fiona Williams as Herself Richard Shelby as Himself Gay Hardwick as Herself Bob Hardwick as Himself Linda O'Dell as Herself Jennifer Carole as Herself Debbi Dominigo as Herself Bonnie Colwell as Herself Nick Willick voices Himself Wes Ryland as Himself Lisa Ortiz as Herself Michelle Cruz as Herself