Guest Stars Justin Kirk as Hamilton Burger Gayle Rankin as Emily Dodson Molly Ephraim as Hazel Prystock Andrew Howard as Detective Joe Ennis Robert Patrick as Herman Baggerly Lili Taylor as Birdy McKeegan Stephen Root as Maynard Barnes David Wilson Barnes as Elder Brown Veronica Falcón as Lupe Gibbs Taylor Nichols as Elder Eric Q. Seidel Nate Corddry as Matthew Dodson Matt Frewer as Judge Frederick Wright Jefferson Mays as Virgil Sheets Aaron Stanford as George Gannon Stacie Greenwell as Nina Preer Todd Weeks as Jim Hicks Kai Lennox as Man with Petrol Co Starring Michael O'Connell as Troy Chisom Forte Rodriguez as Bailiff Bobby Reed as Juror Kevin Garbee as Juror Foreman Eileen Fogarty as Madam Jin Jeff Bowser as Withered Man Pamela Chau as Tang Yin Jack Kennedy as Cop Chuck Filipov as Taxi Guy Jim O'Brien as Rabblerouser Stuart Yee as Shopkeeper Michael Thomas Wallace as Revelations Man Xinna Lai as Girl Madam Jin's Michael Drake Krueger as Centurion Austin R. Grant as Frat Guy Ella Kennedy Davis as Young Alice McKeegan J.J. Clark as Good Looking Waiter Jeremiah Miller as Savior Belle Adams as Beautiful Woman Joanna Delane as Housekeeper Keith Barber as Private Vic Marrin Shawn Patrick Clifford as Sister Alice Frat Guy Michael Pantozzi as Centurion Leslie Simms as Motel Manager David L.M. McIntyre as Centurion Justin Tinucci as Frat Guy John O'Brien as Ernie Magnuson Payam Banifaz as Jiminy Cricket Man Carrie Armstrong as Bible Woman