Guest Stars Clare McNulty as Chantal Witherbottom Cole Escola as Chip Ron Livingston as Keith Michaela Watkins as Polly Louie Anderson as Bob Judy Reyes as Deb Co Starring Phoebe Tyers as April Charlie Covey as Reid Conor William Wright as Aaron Jane Gabbert as Kathy Paul O'Brien as Frank Jim Santangeli as Garrett Jamar Greene as Deputy Mary Stout as Stenographer Michele Tauber as Ms. Kiwi Raphael Nash Thompson as Judge Hellerman Sebastian Conelli as Paparazzo #1 Maria Elena Ramirez as News Correspondent Madison Elizabeth Lagares as Kaitlin Cezar Williams as Crazy Person #2 Lisha Brooks as Crazy Person #1 Julie Chateauvert as Juror #1 Edward Manley as FBI Agent