Guest Stars Jessica Lynn Skinner as Kayla Landis Haley Tju as Rachelle Cohen-Strauss Jacob Skidmore as AJ Andrew Jacobs as Ben Truax Chloë Levine as Jillian Nik Dodani as Chase Rao Austin Crute as Marquise Co Starring Anna Lynne Nelson as Katie Michael Cojocaru as Guy Reed Morris as Drunk Dude Steven Patterson as Rachelle's Dad