Guest Stars McKinley Belcher III as Broadnax Steve Zahn as Chase Alex Sharp as Preacher Kelley Davis as Miss Abby Kwame Patterson as Darg Jeremy Childs as Judge Fuggett Natasha Marc as Pie Crystal Lee Brown as Sibonia Alexis Louder as Libby Co Starring Chance McCoy as George Turner Keith Flippen as Slave Master Matt Boliek as Slave Trader Wes Robertson as Man William Tokarsky as Crusty Patron Joshua Sharper as Young Man Russell Shealy as Randy Michael Vitovich as Hangman