Guest Stars Nicholas Gonzalez as Luke Morales John Cho as Andy Brooks Co Starring Richard Cetrone as Headless Horseman Jeremy Owens as Headless Horseman Craig Branham as Headless Horseman Deja Dee as Desk Clerk Erica Page as Chat Lady Vince Pisani as Paul Short Daniel J. Roberts as Tour Guide Allen O'Reilly as Samuel Adams Zach Shirey as Son Rebecca Morris as Mom Paul Burke as Paul Revere