Guest Stars Sam Corlett as Caliban Jonathan Whitesell as Robin Goodfellow Alessandro Juliani as Dr. Cerberus Skye P. Marshall as Mambo Michele Marie Le Fleur Luke Cook as Lucifer Morningstar / Dark Lord Jedidiah Goodacre as Dorian Gray Glynis Davies as Dezmelda Kaylah Zander as Sycorax Samantha Coughlan as Gryla Leanne Khol Young as Pesta Maria Marlow as Mother Hubbard Brahm Taylor as The Uninvited Co Starring Tyler Cotton as Melvin Peter Bundic as Carl Tapper Nelson Leis as Beelzebub John Murphy as Asmodeus MJ Kokolis as Demonic Minion Kayla Deorksen as Mrs. Anderson Evelyn Burke as Lucy Anderson