Guest Stars Sam Corlett as Caliban Jonathan Whitesell as Robin Goodfellow Christopher Rosamond as Mr. Kinkle Luke Cook as Lucifer Morningstar / Dark Lord James Urbaniak as Trinket Man Ron Selmour as Baron Samedi Co Starring Tyler Cotton as Melvin Nelson Leis as Beelzebub Xantha Radley as Mrs. Meeks Whitney Peak as Judith Blackwood Darius Willis as Judas Blackwood Melody Nosipho Niemann as Trick-or-Treat Witch Billy Christos, Jr. as Trick-or-Treat Kid #2 Conor O'Mahony as Trick-or-Treat Kid #3
