Guest Stars Matt Barr as Nick Hawley Francie Swift as Beth Lancaster Co Starring Abigail Cornell as Sara Lancaster Alan Wells as Intermediary John Colton as Daniel Lancaster Katelyn Farrugia as Lancaster's Daughter #2 Ryan Gray as Piper Morgan Hinkleman as Lancaster Daughter Tom Hillmann as Richard Weiss Heather Gilliland as Lancaster's Daughter #1 Erika Edwards as Lancaster's Daughter #3 Ryan Boz as Lancaster-Weiss Brother #1 Christian Scales as Lancaster-Weiss Brother #2 Sterling Santiago Baron as Lancaster-Weiss Brother #3