Guest Stars Todd Williams as Robin Taylor Samantha Marie Ware as Vanessa 'Ness' Johnson Ryan Michelle Bathe as Rachel Audubon Rebecca Field as Carol Coleman Shalim Ortiz as Joaquin Luna Peter MacNicol as Judge Albert Campbell Robyn Lively as Nancy Frost Joel Gretsch as Frank Frost Boone Platt as Deputy Wilson Tyler Barnhardt as Jesse Frost Anna Grace Barlow as Jennifer Siegal Co Starring Ahmad Dugas as Deputy Douglas Shannyn Covington as Dionn Richardson